找回密码 注册 QQ登录
一站式解决方案

iCAx开思网

CAD/CAM/CAE/设计/模具 高清视频【积分说明】如何快速获得积分?快速3D打印 手板模型CNC加工服务在线3D打印服务,上传模型,自动报价
打印 上一主题 下一主题

【讨论】Pro E\UG\CAXA到底谁好?

[复制链接]
71
发表于 2003-3-30 11:37:36 | 只看该作者
DD Doing wrote:
谢谢lizg26   
   
  又学到新东西了,请问CATIA多少钱一套?在什么地方可以买的到呢?  
  
  还有,对计算机的要求有多高?  
  
  PIII 1.3G   384M 跑得起来吗?

你不错,很努力!
内存要大些,建议512M以上,其他没问题!
不要迷信软件本身,我们学工程的应该掌握CAD行业的前沿技术,结合自己的专业知识来应用,在美国有学生版CATIA,约100$,不是我们中国学生用的起,商业版就很贵了!
72
发表于 2003-3-30 11:38:59 | 只看该作者
darkhorse  
   
你的UGNX、CATIA V5R10是正版的吗?
  
多少钱一套?
73
发表于 2003-3-30 11:42:51 | 只看该作者
请问你的windows 2000是正版的马?
  
和你一样我是学生,
我用的软件没有一个是正版的。
CAXA也不是采取了盗版培育市场的策略马?
74
发表于 2003-3-30 11:46:25 | 只看该作者
可惜我的三条内存槽都插满了128M的二手内存;
  
是我好不容易省吃俭用 卖血换回来的 *^_^*
  
已经不能再加了;
  
不知道UG NX 有什么硬件要求呢?我手头刚好有一个版本,两张光盘的。
75
发表于 2003-3-30 11:48:09 | 只看该作者
darkhorse  
   
你是学生吗?我以为你是工程师呢,你怎么这么厉害。
  
私下聊会吧。
76
发表于 2003-3-30 17:55:30 | 只看该作者
惭愧呀,一个名不见经传的学校的学生,
估计你可能没有听说过。
北航这样的学校我是不敢期望,没能力考上。
77
发表于 2003-3-30 22:38:44 | 只看该作者
贴一张图,这可是用CAXA做的哦
  
可惜我还没有这个本事
78
发表于 2003-3-30 23:19:43 | 只看该作者
DD Doing wrote:
SolidWorks做装配能力也非常有限,只能装配平面、圆柱面、球面;连圆锥面都不能装配,更不要提什么齿轮、高级曲面、高副等等的装配了;但是用CAXA就可以很方便的做到所有类型的装配。   
  
  这句话,不知道darkhorse 怎么评价呢?

  
我觉的你只知道一些简单的基本体,或者此类装配。因为你还在学校,可能
你的课程设计就是个减速箱,用caxa得心应手。
可是你知道不知道,外面的很多东西需要曲面。
就像我们公司模具,检具,治具那个重要面不是曲面。而且不像一个花瓶
那么单纯。平面只是基准面,外形面等。
我觉得3d软件,就是要体现曲面的优越功能。表达2维不能表达的东西。
否则用3维干什么。
  
你的齿轮装配,画个简图,工人师傅就一目了然了。
79
发表于 2003-3-31 09:33:12 | 只看该作者
CAXA曲面功能还揍合。。。。。
(注:CAXA实体设计XP在美国及海外市场的英文版名为IRONCAD6.0,属CAXA旗下产品)
  
> Hi, Guys:
>  
> This is a review of IRONCAD 6.0. It talsk a lot on the new surface  
> functions. Many comments can be good feedback for us to consider inthe  
> future. A good step forward to CAXA technology be visible in the world  
> market. Keep moving on!
>  
>>  
> >From: "Steve McGuinness" <smcguinness@ironcad.com>
> >To: "Steve McGuinness" <smcguinness@ironcad.com>
> >Subject: IronCAD 6.0 Mini Review by Joe Greco
> >Date: Fri, 7 Mar 2003 16:08:20 -0500
> >
> >Dear Channel Partners,
> >
> &gtlease see the latest very positive IronCAD review by Joe Greco, one of
> >the leading CAD authorities in the US!
> >
> >https://www.cadenceweb.com/newsletter/mcad/0203_2.html
> >
> >   _____
> >
> >  <https://www.cmp.com> CMP Logo
> >  <https://www.cadenceweb.com/index.html> cadence web
> >
> >
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/toc_magazine.jpg>
> >
> >  <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/issuefocus/index.html> Cover Story
> >CADENCE Lab <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/cadlab/index.html>
> >Reviews <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/reviews/index.html>
> >Columns <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/columns/index.html>
> >Departments <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/departments/index.html>
> >Current Issue <https://www.cadenceweb.com/2003/0203/index.html>
> &gtast Issues <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/archive.html>
> >Special  <https://www.cadenceweb.com/magazine/special_reports/index.html>
> >Reports
> >
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/toc_search.jpg>
> >AEC
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/head.html
> >+search/foot.html+&text=AEC&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=cadence.si
> >te&SortSpec=Score+Desc>
> >GIS
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/head.html
> >+search/foot.html+&text=GIS&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=cadence.si
> >te&SortSpec=Score+Desc>
> >Hardware
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/head.html
> >+search/foot.html+&text=hardware&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=caden
> >ce.site&SortSpec=Score+Desc>
> >Management
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/head.html
> >+search/foot.html+&text=management&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=cad
> >ence.site&SortSpec=Score+Desc>
> >MCAD-
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/headmcad.
> >html+search/footmcad.html+&text=MCAD&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=c
> >adence.site&SortSpec=Score+Desc> Sponsored by
> >
> ><https://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;4652188;7518735;v?https://www.autodesk.com
> >/streamline-trial20>
> >3D
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/scripts/verity/K2capture.cgi?search/head.html
> >+search/foot.html+&text=3D&Submit=search&maxhits=75&database=cadence.sit
> >e&SortSpec=Score+Desc>
> >
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/toc_news.jpg>
> >Headlines <https://www.cadenceweb.com/news/archive/index.html>
> >Newsletters <https://www.cadenceweb.com/newsletter/index.html>
> >
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/toc_community.jpg>
> >Discussion Forums
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/db_area/community/openforum/>
> >Downloads <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/downloads.html>
> >Awards Showcase <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/awards/index.html>
> >CAD Links <https://www.cadenceweb.com/cadlinks/index.html>
> >Events <https://www.cadenceweb.com/events/index.html>
> >CAD  <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/store/index.html> Shop
> >Training <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/training/index.html>
> >Quick Quiz Results <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/quiz/index.html>
> >
> >White  <https://www.cadenceweb.com/community/white_papers/index.html>
> &gtapers
> >
> >Contact Us <https://www.cadenceweb.com/contact/index.html>
> >Advertise <https://www.cadenceweb.com/mediakit/index.html>
> &gtrivacy  <https://www.cmpnet.com/delivery/privacy.html> Statement
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/left_angle.gif>
> >CADENCE MCAD Tech News
> >  \ <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/right_angle.gif>
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> >
> >Home <https://www.cadenceweb.com/>  > Newsletter
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/newsletter/>  > MCAD Tech News
> ><https://www.cadenceweb.com/newsletter/mcad>  > 91
> >
> >
> >
> >Joe Greco
> >CADENCE MCAD Tech News #91 (Feb. 27, 2003)
> >
> >
> >In This Issue:
> >
> >
> >Mini-Review of IronCAD 6
> >
> >
> >* New Surfacing Tools
> >
> >* Other Surfacing Tools
> >
> >* Other Enhancements
> >
> >* Conclusions
> >
> >Mini-Review of IronCAD 6
> >
> >Although IronCAD LLC has undergone many changes over the years, its core
> >MCAD product, also called IronCAD, has remained the company's
> >foundation. IronCAD made its debut in 1998 and immediately gained a lot
> >of attention by employing innovative dragging techniques for creating
> >and editing solids. In late 2001, the developers premiered the
> >InnovationSuite, which included IronCAD, a scaled down version of
> >IronCAD called Inovate, and TeamVault for PDM (Product Data Management).
> >Last year, InnovationSuite 2002 was released. And just this month the
> >package has been upgraded again. Unlike in the March 2002 CADENCE
> >magazine review in which I covered the entire package
> >(https://www.cadenceweb.com/2002/0302/fr0302.html), in this mini-review I
> >am only going to focus on IronCAD 6 (keep in mind that the other
> >components have also been updated).
> >
> >New Surfacing Tools
> >
> >One of the biggest enhancements in IronCAD 6 is the introduction of
> >surfaces. Actually, the program has had the ability to create extruded,
> >revolved, swept, and lofted surfaces for a while, which I will talk
> >about later on, but Version 6 adds six new surfacing tools.
> >
> >All of these new surfacing tools only work with 3D curves, so let's
> >begin with those improvements. For starters, there is a new option to
> >turn 2D curves into 3D ones. In addition, creating 3D curves from
> >scratch also just got easier due to an assortment of new tools. Two of
> >my favorites are: the ability to reverse a curve's end tangency and the
> >way users insert new points on a spline--albeit there doesn't seem to be
> >a way to delete these new points.
> >
> >After I created my first 3D curve, I selected one of its control points
> >and used IronCAD's TriBall to edit its location. Although the program
> >now has the ability to edit points via X, Y, and Z coordinates, most
> >users will prefer the TriBall, which is IronCAD's dynamic positioning
> >tool. It also can be used to copy the curve with or without
> >associativity. After doing so and tweaking each one, I had three
> >different curves in position. I then used the new Loft command. After
> >the first curve is picked, IronCAD needs to know where to anchor that
> >curve. This means another mouse click is required, which really should
> >not be necessary. However, after that it is just a simple matter of
> >selecting the other two curves, and the software gives visual feedback
> >in the form of a red dashed line. This lets the user know which curves
> >make up the loft and the order that they will be used in.
> >
> >IronCAD still maintains its old way of creating a loft, which acts more
> >like a variational sweep as it sweeps a single curve along another
> >curve, and then asks how many loft cross sections are desired in
> >between. It is then possible to go back and edit the cross sections or
> >the curve that defines the path; however, only 2D curves can be used in
> >this original Loft command.
> >
> >While IronCAD 6 doesn't offer true freeform surface deformations, it
> >does allow you to edit underlying curves normally, and then the surface
> >built off of them will automatically update. Technically, the original
> >curves are not part of the surface, as IronCAD preserves them and
> >essentially uses duplicate curves to make the surface. While keeping the
> >original curves can be handy, I feel this should be an option rather
> >than the only choice because having two curves in the same location
> >sometimes results in selection problems. The software also houses new
> >tools for creating swept and revolved surfaces; although, as is the case
> >with lofting, the old techniques are still available with basically the
> >same differences and limitations.
> >
> >Other Surfacing Tools
> >
> >Mesh is a totally new surfacing tool, and it creates what is commonly
> >known as a UV surface. Mesh takes a grid of curves roughly oriented
> >perpendicular to each other and essentially does a bi-directional loft.
> >The 3D curves used in this tool must be touching wherever they
> >intersect, which is a fairly common rule for most programs (except
> >exclusive surfacing applications such as Rhino).
> >
> >Another new surfacing tool is called Edge Surface, which is known as a
> >boundary or fill surface in most 3D applications. This tool is ideal for
> >closing gaps in imported surfaces, by allowing the edges of the opening
> >to be picked, thus forming a boundary. While this is a nice addition to
> >the IronCAD 6 toolbox, the program is limited to only 3- and 4-sided
> >surfaces. There is a tangency control setting to ensure a smooth blend
> >between the new surface and the old, but this can only be set after the
> >surface is built. Also, when I zoomed in on the result, IronCAD did not
> >create a completely watertight surface, as gaps were still apparent.
> >Oddly, if I turned off the tangency setting, these gaps were alleviated,
> >but then the transition wasn't as smooth. IronCAD also allows surfaces
> >to be thickened into a solid, which is handy, and a surface can be
> >duplicated with zero offset and then moved into position with the
> >TriBall.
> >
> >While these tools help make IronCAD more attractive to the product
> >designer, some tools do need a bit more work as well as more options. In
> >addition, there are commands missing such as surface filleting,
> >blending, extending, trimming, untrimming, and zebra stripe analysis.
> >However, even without any of these tools, IronCAD is still an excellent
> >program for conceptual modeling by virtue of how dynamic dragging is
> >incorporated extensively throughout it.
> >
> >Other Enhancements
> >
> >IronCAD 6 also features other modeling improvements. For instance, there
> >are now more ways to specify a chamfer, and the developers also
> >incorporated several miscellaneous assembly enhancements. The 2D
> >drafting capabilities have also been beefed up with the addition of hole
> >tables, auto ballooning, an aligned section tool, new dimension types,
> >and more.
> >
> >Conclusions
> >
> >IronCAD 6 deserves a look by anyone considering the purchase of a solid
> >modeling program (with integrated PDM)--not so much based on what's new,
> >but what's old. I'm not putting down the new stuff--it is helpful--but
> >the strength of the program is still in its intuitive approach to solid
> >modeling, something no other MCAD vendor has been able to duplicate.
> >
> >Relevant Links
> >
> >IronCAD: https://www.ironcad.com
> >
> >About the Author
> >
> >Joe Greco is a freelance CAD writer, consultant, and trainer based in
> >Flagstaff, AZ. He is also a contributing editor to CADENCE magazine. You
> >can reach him at joegreco@yahoo.com.
> >
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> >   <https://www.cadenceweb.com/images/nav_images/spacer.gif>
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >(c) 1997-2003 CMP. All rights reserved.
> >
> >  <https://www.cmp.com/delivery/privacy.html> Privacy statement
> >
> >
> >
>  
>  
> _________________________________________________________________
> Protect your PC - get McAfee.com VirusScan Online   
> https://clinic.mcafee.com/clinic/ibuy/campaign.asp?cid=3963
>
80
发表于 2003-3-31 11:57:15 | 只看该作者
[quote]DD Doing wrote:
贴一张图,这可是用CAXA做的哦  
  
  可是这张图中的螺旋桨是用proe做的啊::?
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册

本版积分规则

3D打印手板模型快速制作服务,在线报价下单!

QQ 咨询|手机版|联系我们|iCAx开思网  

GMT+8, 2024-12-25 02:04 , Processed in 0.037816 second(s), 8 queries , Gzip On, Redis On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.3

© 2002-2024 www.iCAx.org

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表